Hiroh Kikai's Asakusa Portraits is a book of, well, portraits taken in Asakusa, a district of northeast Tokyo. It's a place that has rich history and "feel stranded in time." It used to be known as a "place where eccentricity, indulgence, and stubborn individuality could flourish," but is now known as "a kind of urban backwater lying well outside the itinerary of foreign tourists." It used to also be Tokyo's main pleasure quarters--and all kind of pleasures of all kind, if you know what I am saying.
Hiroh Kikai began this extended street portrait series after graduating with a degree in philosophy in 1973 until this 2008 ICP/Steidl publication (Stephan's probably seen this book and "salivated"). Kikai developed his photographic approach to this series or "game rules" that has remained virtually unaltered to the present." He picks the people he wants in the busy crowd, excluding those wearing designer clothing because it "would identify too closely with specific moment in time." He uses a medium format Hasselblad with black and white film to captures the subjects personality and character.
Accompanying each photograph is a caption that seems out there and sometimes not evident from the photograph--personal traits or events that shaped their life story--which Hiroh Kikai gets from the few lines he jots down after every brief encounter. He says he wants his photographs to create a 'two-way conversation between the viewer and the picture.'
After the introduction to how this project began, we get a conversation that Hiroh Kikai had with Noriko Fuku. They are questions and answers about his background, Asakusa Portraits, and the fact that he is not really well recognized or received in Japan compared to his contemporaries and among his contemporaries. He has never has a solo exhibition in a Japanese museum. This part of the book, which is ten pages long, is really interesting because I've never seen it in another photo book. It's a personal approach to finding out more about the photographer, himself. It isn't as direct. It's not as direct either.
The photographs themselves are so stunning. They are impeccably printed. The tonal range is perfect. They are always open prints, which is what I like the most. The contrast isn't so in your face, but the darks and blacks are their. It's subtle. This is my cup of tea. I always wanted to try medium format and shoot, just to a get a feel for it, but haven't really been able to yet. I tried once but I didn't want to lug around my 35mm with me too to meter, so it never happened.
They are quite a collection of photographs--from rather plain-looking to the absolutely ridiculous. The plain ones often have the best captions, as well. Although I could not deduce whatever the caption says for the most part in the photograph, I am happy they were included. A great example is page 115. The man photographed is making a strange face, has interesting glasses, and is basically covered head to toe. This would be a pretty average portrait, however, the caption quotes something the man said to Kikai. It says, 'Today the cold has even reached my dentures.' This is a great line and adds more because he is puckering up and them I understand why the scarf rapped around his head like a woman. The caption works in conjunction with the photograph.
If and when I make a book of the 4x5 project I did (if not for me then for that sweet couple who were gracious enough to let me in their home and make those photographs), I would definitely use this approach. Some of the things he told me were just too good and made the experience I had with him even better. They definitely add even more to the photographs.
What's amazing is that Hiroh Kikai ran into the same people years later and photographed them again. It makes for an interesting comparison. An example of this is a man holding a dog Kikai photographed in 1986. He photographed the same man twenty-one years later in 2007 holding a different dog.
That being said, there are ones where the caption is far better than the photograph itself and could have been done without if the caption wasn't interesting. The caption says, "An only child who's the daughter her father always wanted." The photograph is OK, but a "filler" and not "killer" and one of the weaker ones out of the group.
The photograph beside it on page 231 is one of my favorites both for its caption and the photograph, itself. I can see some type of pain in the face he is making and the caption makes us understand why. It says, "A man who burst into tears on hearing my northeastern dialect, saying it reminded him of a late friend." It's a good example of the them working together. I also like it because I feel like I was there with him, too and am sharing in some of the moments Hiroh Kikai with all of these people.
This makes me then go on to look at the page spreads and I wonder sometimes why he chose the two portraits to be on the same page because I don't understand the connection. The double page spread on page 230 and 231 doesn't really make sense. I question if they were taken into consideration or was the goal to have them all work in the larger group. An awesome spread is on page 64 and 65. Both of the men's eyes are slightly shut. The one on the left because there is something wrong with his right eye, but the man on the right looks like he was squinting. I begin to compare to two because of this after looking at each of them.
These make me want to try to do something like this,too. This is mostly because of the different people I would get to meet and the little things I get to learn about them. However, I don't think this would have the same outcome in New York. I would probably hear far more profanities, than stories--which could be interesting to document as well, but a different project. There are some gems in here like page 43. The man is wearing old woolen long johns and his fly is open from sitting. The face is making adds to the comedy of this photograph. The spread is great, too. The photograph on page 42 is of a boy wearing a mask and there are round holes for his eyes and mouth and I see the comparison and the funny pairing.
Other great ones to check out are pages 50, 55, 75, 90, 136 155, 159, 187, and 227.